New to Meducation?
Sign up
Already signed up? Log In
Blog

Doctors’ Rotas: The Jokes, The Incompetence and The Illegal

Righting the wrongs of rotas

Written by jacob matthews · Thursday 17th March 2016

Unless you live in a cave I am sure you will all be aware of the current level of discontent among doctors. Most of the discontent is being brought to a peak because of the contract “re-negotiations”, however beneath the headlines lie the same old issues that plaque a doctors working life.

Warning: this is about to become a rant…

A few days ago, a friend of mine asked me to look at their rota for their next job. The job is a 1a banded job doing acute medicine at a small hospital, that is part of a larger trust. The banding of 1a reflects the number of hours worked (40-48h/week) and the level of anti-social hours (>1/3) which correlates with an increase in pay above the base rate. So in effect this “contract” means that a doctor will be working 48h a week with on average 1 night and 1 weekend shift a week.

So far, so average, where is the rant I hear you ask?

If I were to say that 2 people were contracted to work the same hours and the same proportion of antisocial work, you would assume that they would get paid the same right? And vice versa, if I were to say one person was told to work more shifts, more antisocial hours and have less time off, that person should be paid more, correct?


Apparently not! The NHS seems to think it's perfectly fair to force some doctors to work more than their colleagues for exactly the same pay and sometimes less time off. How can this be fair? How can this be legal?
My friend sent me their rota on an Excel spreadsheet and within 10 minutes I was able to create the following table 1:

Image title



This table clear displays the total number of on call shifts for each junior on the rota, it shows their “zero hour” rota’ed off days to make them EWTD compliant, it also shows the “net” shifts which is the total minus the off days. It was not difficult to work out the mean number of shifts and off days per doctor. The cells highlighted in blue are the doctors who have got a “good” deal, by random chance they have less on calls and more off days than their fellows, while still getting the exact same pay. The cells highlighted in red are those who have got a “bad” deal with more on call shifts AND less days off. This rota is clearly NOT FAIR!

Every shift on this rota could be easily covered if 6 doctors worked 13 shifts and 3 worked 14 shifts. There are 3 antisocial shift groups, therefore 3 doctors take the extra shifts in each block, as seen in the below table.

Image title


Table 2 clearly shows that all of the shifts can be easily covered by a simple change in rota that now makes the rota completely fair, with equal antisocial hours, equal shifts and equal time off. Working this out has taken me exactly 20 minutes, including colour coding and table formatting. If I can do this then why can’t the rota “administrator” (NOT A MANAGER!!!)?

Why is it the “done thing” that rota “managers” are allowed to bully hard working doctors into accepting unfair rotas?

From personal experience, when these issues are raised with the incompetents in question they have a number of stock answers for dismissing any complaints. Here are a few:

“Doctors should get used to unfair rota’s as this will always happen, and is a random process, so at some future point you might end up doing less work with more time off, so don’t complain now.”

“The shifts can’t be organised any other way” – Please see table 2.

“The rota software won’t let us change the way the shifts are allocated” – then don’t use that software, use an Excel sheet that is perfectly plastic.

“The rota is calculated over x weeks (could be 9, 17, 23 or 56 weeks) and therefore if you stayed here longer it would all work out fairly.” – Junior doctors ALWAYS work the same number of weeks in each job. For Foundation doctors it is ALWAYS 4 months!!! Sooo… get off your lazy arses and write a NEW rota that works over 4 months, NOT 7.3 months or so other ridiculous, random length.

“The EWTD and New Deal don’t dictate individual doctors’ hours, only “rota” hours (averaged out over all doctors on the rota), therefore we don’t have to change anything, you just have to accept what we give you.” – I don’t care if the EWTD and New Deal are poorly written and designed, and so full of loop holes that they are almost entirely meaningless. It is lazy and CALLUS to force people to work harder for less money just because the rota is “technically” compliant with the law. It still feels illegal to me to make 1 individual work more hours and get paid the same as someone working less than them.

Rota’s are a constant issue for junior doctors, no matter what the technicalities of the exact contract are. Is it surprising that the morale of junior doctors is at an all time low when they are forced to work in conditions like this? The NHS bureaucracy is callus, lazy and full of “job’s worths” who couldn’t find their way out of a paper bag. These people should not be employed! They certainly should not be left in charge of organising a rota and they most definitely should not have a veto on the lives of over-worked, under-paid junior doctors. If I was ever put in a position of authority in an NHS organisation, on my first day I would FIRE the entire rota department and then hire just 1 intelligent individual to do the work of the current 10, but pay them a larger salary to actually attract someone who knows how to use Excel efficiently.

If I could make one plea here it would be for the NHS to give clinicians the power to design and control their own rotas. I would happily take on the responsibility of being in charge of the rota for whatever job I am working on and I am almost 100% sure that I would be able to make the normal working life of junior clinicians less stressful and improve their morale by letting them work in an environment that they think is fair and cares about their welfare. Is it too much to ask to be allowed to work in a FAIR working environment?

References:

http://www.idwl.info/workinghours.html

http://medical-dictionary.thefreedictionary.com/pay+band+1A%5D

http://www.bma.org.uk/support-at-work/ewtd/ewtd-juniors

Responses

AndyW
·
Student
·
Posted 3 months ago
Had the same problem with the Jokes, the Incompetence and the Illegal, and we wrote to assignment assistance online help to solve this problem, Hope they will help us
Like
(1)
Respond
flipdiving
·
Posted about 2 months ago
If any page has quality posts like yours then I will search for information very quickly. Please donate again nodejs quiz
Like
(1)
Respond
dinesh shanz
·
Posted 2 months ago
Download Viber for pc is one such famous messaging application specially developed to deliver the messages all over the world instantly.
Like
(0)
Respond
Deleted User
·
Posted 3 months ago
Very good, I think I found the knowledge I needed. I will see and refer some information in your post. thank you. bloxorz
Like
(0)
Respond
happy wheels
·
Posted 3 months ago
Thanks for your article! I have been looking for quite a long time and fortunately I read this article! I wish you would continue to have valuable articles like this or more to share with everyone! vex 3
Like
(0)
Respond
Cricket Betting Tips
·
Cricket Betting Tips - Cricket Betting Tips
·
Posted 3 months ago
Like
(0)
Respond
html color
·
Posted 3 months ago
Your article is easy to understand, the simple way of communicating is accessible to the majority of people. I will keep track of your posts regularly. html color picker
Like
(0)
Respond
Lynn Libbrecht
·
Posted 3 months ago
Like
(0)
Respond
andrewsymond
·
Writer - mocrosoft
·
Posted 3 months ago
Had a similar issue with the Jokes, the Incompetence and the Illegal, and we wrote to sssssss help to take care of this issue, Hope they will help us CourseworkGeek
Like
(0)
Respond
Deleted User
·
Posted 3 months ago
I’m thoroughly enjoying your blog. I too am an aspiring blog writer but I’m still new to the whole thing. Do you have any helpful hints for newbie blog writers? I’d certainly appreciate it. bloxorz
Like
(0)
Respond
brainwave74
·
IT Expert - new york
·
Posted 2 months ago
Like
(0)
Respond
Deleted User
·
Posted 2 months ago
The knowledge you share really changes me in life, I sincerely thank you for the things you have done, sure your blog will help more people. Sincerely thanks slither
Like
(0)
Respond
Lisa Harris
·
Posted over 1 year ago
Great article as always! This article is written with some new variations for the positive results. chris evans civil war jacket at amazon
Like
(0)
Respond
JackPonting
·
Medical/Nursing Academic Writer - London Business School
·
Posted 8 months ago
I am sharing this important article with my medial students who are taking help with assignment writing UK from the academic experts.
Like
(0)
Respond
Gracie Willow
·
Photographer - Coursework Club
·
Posted about 2 months ago
I will definitely try to solve this issue as soon as possible..
Like
(0)
Respond
Deleted User
·
Posted about 1 month ago
Like
(0)
Respond
teraz
·
medical - oxford
·
Posted 24 days ago
I regard this post.Here is major portrayal about the article matter which helped me more. ntts
Like
(0)
Respond
Dedi Galih Wisnumurti
·
Doctoor - Gunadarma University
·
Posted 19 days ago
Enjoy and Visit : 1. MP3 2. MP3 Download 3. Sewa Villa di Puncak 4. Villa Puncak x
Like
(0)
Respond
ID TECHR
·
Doctor - UNVI
·
Posted 15 days ago
Very interesting thank you for making the article useful for me
New information for you :
1. Jasa SEO
2. Jasa Pembuatan Website
d
Like
(0)
Respond
Bless
·
Posted 11 days ago
Pretty cool site with lots of useful content: http://vitalhealthrecipes.com/quick-potato-recipes/
Like
(0)
Respond
Bless
·
Posted 10 days ago
Like
(0)
Respond
teraz
·
medical - oxford
·
Posted 5 days ago
I obviously with respect to every last piece of it. It is a huge site and not to a unimaginable degree upsetting give. manabadi hall tickets 2018
Like
(0)
Respond
Bless
·
Posted 2 days ago
Nicely written: meloxicam 15 mg high
Like
(0)
Respond
teraz
·
medical - oxford
·
Posted about 17 hours ago
I was undeniably filtering for. It was luxuriously formed and contained sound, sensible offer. phenq bad reviews
Like
(0)
Respond